Hearing protection selection tool
Choosing the right hearing protection can seem like an impossible task sometimes.
This tool allows you to enter your noise level and it will give a list of suitable hearing protectors, listed by name, type and expected noise level under the protector - the noise people actually hear.
It can also be filtered by type, so muffs, plugs, detectable plugs, clip-on muffs for hard hats, etc.
Key points: Hearing protection selection tool
Enter your noise level - use the average dB(C).
If you don’t have the average dB(C), enter the average dB(A). This is normally within a few dB of the average dB(C) so will be in the right area, but to be totally correct you should use the average dB(C).
The HSE say in L108 that you should aim for a noise level at the ear of around 70 to 78 dB so this is the range which comes up as ‘suitable’ in this tool.
There are also options for showing protectors which give too much noise reduction (over-protecting) or too little (under protecting).
For more guidance on how to choose the right hearing protection, and for other tools such as checking a specific SNR against your noise risk, see the Choosing the Right Hearing Protection page.
Types of hearing protection
Muff (electronic) - fancy ones with active noise suppression and speech pass-through at lower noise levels.
Muff (folding) - the headband folds against the cups so it is smaller in storage, otherwise same as standard headband ones.
Muff (headband) - your standard over-the-head style of ear muff.
Muff (helmet) - a helmet / hard-hat mounted ear muff, one which clips on to a hard hat.
Muff (music) - an ear muff which has Bluetooth (or less commonly these days, an aux connection) for music playback.
Muff (multi-position) - a muff where the band can go over the head or round the neck, while keeping the muff in position.
Muff (neckband) - one where the band goes round the neck rather than over the head, handy if wearing bump caps, etc.
Plug - your standard in-ear plug. Could be disposable or reusable depending on type.
Plug (banded) - has soft plug-style ends which typically sit on the ear canal rather than inside it, connected by a hard plastic band.
Plug (corded) - where the two plugs have a soft cord connecting them so they can hang around the neck.
Plug (custom) - custom-moulded ear plugs, made from a mould of the person’s ear.
Plug (detectable) - a metal detectable ear plug so classed as ‘food safe’. Stops it appearing in people’s dinner.
Plug (music) - like the muffs, a plug which has Bluetooth for music playback.
| Manufacturer ▲ | Protector ▲ | Type ▲ | SNR ▲ | At ear ▲ | Reusable ▲ | Comments |
|---|
Formula: L'Aeq = LCeq − SNR + 4 (HSE L108). Suitable = 70–78 dB at the ear. SNR values from manufacturer data sheets — verify for your environment.
Specsavers custom ear plugs: These are not included as Specsavers make no performance data available for their Specsavers Advance Work custom ear plugs. I would recommend they are not used at work.
More advice and guidance on specific areas of hearing protection at work
As I have spent over 30 years working in workplace noise safety, I’ve identified some of the common issues and questions which come up with hearing protection and put together short articles giving advice and guidance on them.
Portwest have released the PW77 ear defenders which have Bluetooth for music playback, and are charging what appears to be an exceptionally good price for them, but are they any good? Short answer, yes.
A review of the Portwest PW74 Dual SNR Ear Defenders. These a new and innovative product which allow the wearer to switch between noise reduction levels of 25 and 35 dB. But, what are they actually like in use?
Most hearing protection does have a set life expectancy and will ‘expire’ after a set time, even if not in use. A typical shelf life for hearing protection is five years, or lower for more budget options. This is how long hearing protection can last for before needing to be replaced.
Specsavers sell a custom ear plug called Specsavers Advance Work, but appear to have no EN 352 certification or certified performance data. When you delve into the brochure their definition of ‘work’ appears to be DIY tools. Specsavers custom ear plugs should not be used at work as hearing protection.
There are a lot of hearing protectors available on places such as eBay and Amazon, some of which look quite slick, but they are not always a good choice for use at work. Sometimes they specifically don’t actually mention workplaces, while others have inaccurate listings or are missing key information.
There is a common belief that ear muffs (ear defenders) are better in terms of hearing protection than ear plugs, but is this actually true? The answer is ‘no’, they are just different, but they are not better. There is actually an argument they may be worse as they are easier to use incorrectly.
When it comes to noise assessments, managing noise risks and issuing hearing protection, employers need to monitor and enforce usage but also importantly have a system in place for checking the hearing protection is still suitable for use and is not deteriorating or damaged.
Over-protection often comes from well-meaning employers buying the strongest hearing protection they can find - hearing protection with the highest SNR. They mean well but it often actually increases risk and for the employer, means more of the money they spend on hearing protection is wasted.
A need for hearing protection is a common outcome of a noise assessment or a noise survey but how do you choose the right hearing protection for your noise risk, especially as 'strongest is best' is usually not the case.
Apple’s AirPods Pro 3 and their EN 352 certified hearing protection function are a potential game-changer in terms of what is possible with hearing protection. This is an overview of their use as hearing protection at work in the UK, my thoughts on them after trying them on noise assessments, and a comparison to the current best-in-the-business for Bluetooth hearing protection, ISOTunes.
Can someone use noise cancelling headphones in place of hearing protection in a high noise environment? For most headphones, no, they cannot be used as hearing protection. An exception is the Apple AirPods Pro 3 which do have an EN 352 certified SNR.
Hearing protection for use at work must be certified to EN 352. This is a dive into what EN 352 means, what the various revisions of it are and which ones are now defunct, and which are the current standards for hearing protection.
It is common to hear someone claim a medical exemption from the need to wear hearing protection at work, sometimes backed up with a note or letter from a GP, or sometimes self-claimed, but are medical exemptions from the need to wear hearing protection possible?
In a noise assessment, it is common to hear a comment along the lines of ‘we’ve given them hearing protection and told them to wear it, so what else can we do’, but that is not the end of the employer’s obligations for hearing protection.
A common recommendation from Occupational Health Physicians is ‘recommend wear double hearing protection’. What they are saying is that the person concerned wears two sets of hearing protection but this often has no link to the findings of the noise assessment.
Disposable ear plugs have a low per-pair cost but that cost can soon mount up and it is tempting for employers to limit how many pairs people can use in a given period. This is not a good approach, cannot be done and is poor for safety.
Loop have emerged as one of the newer entrants in the hearing protection world with a lot of their marketing focused on social media, but is it marketing BS or does the Loop ear plug performance match up? I bought a couple of styles to try when out on noise assessments, to see how they perform for noise attenuation and for long-term comfort.
A common issue following a noise assessment concerns people who wear hearing aids but who also work in a high noise area so fall into the requirements for hearing protection to be worn. This is some advice on how to manage it.
Hearing protection comes in a very wide range of prices, but is price consistent with ‘better’ hearing protection?
Often people offer to sign a disclaimer saying they accept the risk of hearing damage from not wearing protection, or they produce a letter from a doctor saying they do not have to wear it, but both are no good.
Sometimes people will say using ear plugs causes them to get ear infections, but do ear plugs actually cause infections? Short answer, no. Dirty hands putting them in, that can cause an infection, but not the plugs themselves.
There is no exemption from the need to wear hearing protection for forklift drivers. High noise will have the same impact on them as on any other person. Their hearing will still be damaged by noise.

